Skip to main content

The Procrustean Bed of ISO29119


The old stories can teach us a great deal. Every once in a while I see the parallels between antiquity and the present, shown through the lens of one of these stories.

The tale of Procrustes (first introduced to me by the work of Nassim Nicholas Taleb, he writes with great skill and knowledge) and the introduction of the "ISO29119 standard" resonate with each other in my mind.

The Tale of Procrustes in a Nutshell......
"Procrustes kept a house by the side of the road where he offered hospitality to passing strangers, who were invited in for a pleasant meal and a night's rest in his very special bed. Procrustes described it as having the unique property that its length exactly matched whomsoever lay down upon it. What Procrustes didn't volunteer was the method by which this "one-size-fits-all" was achieved, namely as soon as the guest lay down Procrustes went to work upon him, stretching him on the rack if he was too short for the bed and chopping off his legs if he was too long."
(Source : mythweb.com)

So, lets adapt this for our ISO29119 situation:
"The "ISO29119 standard" purports to be the only internationally-recognized and agreed standards for software testing, which will provide your organization with a high-quality approach to testing that can be communicated throughout the world. Advocates describe it as having the unique property that it offers offers a set of standards which can be used in any software development life cycle. What the advocates don't volunteer is that your business problem will need to be stretched or trimmed to meet the new standard. So rather than testing solving your business problem, the focus will be to deliver to the standard."
Who will be Theseus for the Craft of Testing?

In the end, Theseus (as part of his tests) dealt with Procrustes using his own vicious device. However this will most likely not be the case here, I believe most thinking testers are advocating the opposite, continuing to champion the principles of Context Driven Testing. Rightly so, merely rubbishing standards is only one half of the argument. I sincerely hope our community of minds will be our Theseus but time will tell. The uptake of the "ISO29119 standard" is an unknown, concerns are probably in large organisations and government, where group (and double) think can be prevalent, these are the soft targets for peddlers of the cult of the same. 

However all over the development world we desperately and continuously strive to leap into Procrustean Beds. Taking shallow solace in "standards", which humans have been doing for a long, long time as a proxy for thought. Once you jump into a Procrustean Bed, you never emerge quite the same.......

Consider investigating..................
http://www.amazon.co.uk/The-Bed-Procrustes-Philosophical-Practical/dp/0241954096
http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/stop29119
http://www.professionaltestersmanifesto.org
http://www.softwaretestingstandard.org
http://www.ministryoftesting.com/2014/08/iso-29119-debate


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Testers Guide to Myths of Unit Testing

One area that testers might be able to enhance their contributions to software development teams is how we perceive and contribute to unit testing. I believe testers busting their own illusions about this aspect of building something good would bring us much closer to developers, and help us realise what other layers of testing can cover most effectively.

Also, I want to do a talk about it, so I figured I would test the premise, see if potential audiences were into it. I put this on Twitter:
Working on a talk about what testers might believe about unit #testing & how we interact with developers creating unit tests. Any challenges/additions for my list below? #development#agilepic.twitter.com/4oT5HE4qs3 — Ash Winter (@northern_tester) December 19, 201730 replies with ideas tends to indicate that people might be into it. 
The ListI thought, as my final blog of 2017, I would provide a super useful list of the myths and legends we as testers might believe about unit testing:
That developer…

Wheel of Testing Part 3 - Applications

I've only had to quit two jobs to finally find the time to finish this blog series. Winning at life. If you need reminders (like I did) check out Part 1 and Part 2 before reading on...

After the first two blogs regarding the Wheel of Testing, I was delighted to receive a few requests for the wheel itself, which got me thinking about applications of it, beyond what its original intent was, which I've explored in detail in part 1 of this series of intermittent blogs. Most models need a little air time to show their value, in software development we crank out models all the time, but I'm not sure how many get used. I am inspired by models such as the "Heuristic Test Strategy Model" by James Marcus Bach, as I have used it and seen the benefits it has brought for my clients, particularly the ability to ask questions. So, I wanted to create a model which has a number of use cases, both real and imagined:

Helping to unlocking a career in testing which may be stuck

It is no…

The Team Test for Testability

You know what I see quite a lot. Really long-winded test maturity models. 

You know what I love to see? Really fast, meaningful ways to build a picture of your teams current state and provoke a conversation about improvement. The excellent test improvement card game by Huib Schoots and Joep Schuurkes is a great example. I also really like 'The Joel Test' by Joel Spolsky, a number of questions you can answer yes or no to to gain insight into their effectiveness as a software development team.

I thought something like this for testability might an interesting experiment, so here goes:

If you ask the team to change their codebase do they react positively?Does each member of the team have access to the system source control?Does the team know which parts of the codebase are subject to the most change?Does the team collaborate regularly with teams that maintain their dependencies?Does the team have regular contact with the users of the system?Can you set your system into a given state…